Be-friending an ex seems to be pretty clear. I've found in my discussions with friends that it can be possible under certain circumstances (i.e. both parties mutually fall out of love) or not possible at all (all other circumstances). The thing is my
ex and I were never just 'friends'. We had met online with the intention to click with someone and well... we clicked. So when I grew
unhappy in our relationship the hardest thing to imagine was letting go of the companionship that we shared... the friendship that we had built. I always thought that if my ex and I broke up that we would be able to continue to be great friends. So when we did
break up I never expected him to ignore my calls, send distant replies to my emails and to not initiate contact with me at all. When we broke up, I thought we were ending our relationship, I had no idea that he was breaking up with me as a friend too.
To add salt to the wound, shortly after our break I had heard some really hurtful things that he had said to others, although he denies them all, it's hard not to believe them when I was thinking these 'hurtful things' already. And then when his denials came from a defensive place rather than a place of concern and confusion, I couldn't help but believe my gut. His actions and words really didn't acknowledge the hurt I was experiencing and he never admitted to his own hurt feelings or loss of the relationship we had had.
Back in the fall, a couple months after I had deleted him from Facebook I found out that he still hadn't deleted any of the photos of me. I had deleted him from Facebook in part because of the hurtful things I had heard and in part for finding him online dating weeks after we broke up (I mean honestly, I get that the easiest way of getting over someone is meeting someone new... but he really couldn't have waited longer than 2 weeks!? We were planning on moving in together!). Him having photos of us as a couple bothered me. I had already deleted all photos with him... I just really couldn't bare to look at photos of us being 'happy' wondering if he even loved me then. I didn't understand why he didn't delete the ones of me!? Why keep them? So after having a bit too much wine with a friend over dinner I decided to email my ex and ask him to delete the photos of me on his Facebook because someone might think that he cares about me (yep, that's what I said, this is why I avoided alcohol for the first month after the break up... ! D.A.N.G.E.R). He responded letting me know that he still does care about me and that he would like to keep some of the photos of us. I responded by saying that 'care' could really mean anything... you may 'care' that I don't get hit by a bus, OR you may actually care about me and be sad that we aren't chatting, I asked him to delete all his photos of me, and he did.
But that got us talking and so we corresponded back and forth for a little while and finally decided to meet. We both seemed to want to work on a friendship, although in the back of my head I questioned whether or not he wanted to be friends to clear his conscience or not, but thought best to meet him and figure it out in person. When we met we spent about an hour just chit chatting and then we got down to 'business.' I asked him what kind of friends he wanted to be, he said the type of friends that run in to each other and can catch up and chat, that can gmail chat and have quick catch ups and maybe catch a movie every once in a while (you know, the very low maintenance kind of friends). Unfortunately, I wanted something very different, I wanted OUR friendship back. My expectations may have been a bit unreasonable, but I had talked to him pretty much everyday since we had first met... and honestly, it was still quite soon after the break and I really just wanted a lot to go back to being the same, minus the sleepovers, the errand running and the intimate stuff. And well, he had lost my trust, so we weren't 'low-maintenance' friend material, he needed to earn my trust back. But he said that it was important to him that we be friends and if that meant he needed to earn my trust back to get our friendship back then he would do it. Wanna know how good he's been since our meeting? Well he's cancelled on me, he's called me up one Saturday to see if I was free in about 30 min, and then sort of cancelled on me again by telling me that he wasn't able to meet me before my trip to Morocco because he has to work late (my ex worked late oh about 3 times when we were together, and worked no later then 6 PM... so ya, I didn't really believe him).
Almost all my friends think that my ex doesn't deserve my friendship, one of my friends has even admitted to getting her back up when his name is mentioned because she is so disappointed in his actions, my family generally think he's been a jerk since we broke up, my boss (yes my boss knows all about the break up) even said to me 'Megan, if he didn't give you what you wanted in your relationship, he most likely won't give you what you want in a friendship'. So here's the question... why the hell do I want to be friends with this guy!? Am I that much of a glutton for punishment??? Have I had a secret relationship lobotomy where I'm a complete dufus when it comes to men I've had feelings for?? I mean really what's wrong with me!? And then a friend of mine gave me some perspective, she understood my desire to be friends with this guy who really hasn't given me a whole lot in return and said 'Megan, it makes perfect sense, you've spent nearly 2 years working at this relationship, putting endless hours in building a friendship and just like that all that work has been 'wasted' (sort of like working for the government, you do a whole lot of work that more likely than not gets tossed). And it's true, maybe I'm not a masochist so much as I'm a total type A personality... in both my work life and my relationship life... I want to be the best girlfriend ever, and if I can't be that I'm going to be the bestest friend... totally weird, but it is so my MO. I sometimes wonder if I did get everything I yearned for from my ex (a genuine apology for leading me on because I was convenient help for him, for being a coward when we broke up by taking the easy route, and acknowledging that I was and am a pretty awesome person and that he is embarrassed for taking advantage of my kindness), if this was done, I just might be able to put this relationship to rest because my efforts will have been recognized. Why I feel I need this, I don't know. Will I ever get it... um, probably not.
As for a friendship... I think I'm slowly coming to terms that my energy, kindness and effort is better not wasted on someone who may just 'care' that I don't get hit by a bus. Have I failed? Well, I don't know. I think what I have to learn is that when you give someone all your love you've never failed, no one's perfect, everyone makes mistakes, but it's how you handle those mistakes that matter, how you choose to treat someone, including an ex-lover matters. At the end of the day I can only control what I do. It's up to my ex to figure his own shit out, it just sucks that I was a by-product of that figuring out process. And who knows, maybe when he's figured his shit out, he will recognize how much I put in to our relationship, and the caring friend that I am and maybe, just maybe he will be willing to put in that same effort in to a new friendship. He's just not ready yet, and I'm not ready to work on a friendship until he's there.